The Keys' Only Authentic NY-Style Bagel Shop

🌟 Famous For: New York/New Jersey-Style Bagels & Creative Flavors

📍 Location: 11090 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050  
📏 Distance from East Sister Rock: ~2 miles  
💰 Price Range: $-$$ (Budget-friendly to Moderate)  
⏰ Hours: 6:30am - 2pm (Closed Mondays)

About:

Marathon Bagel Co. is the Florida Keys' only genuine New York/New Jersey-style bagel shop, serving authentic bagels made with 14% protein rolls for that perfect chewy texture. Open six days a week (closed Mondays) from 6:30am to 2pm, this local favorite offers all-day breakfast and lunch with creative bagel flavors and hearty breakfast sandwiches.

Choose from classic bagel and cream cheese combinations or try unique flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Jalapeño-Cheddar, and Oreo. The breakfast sandwiches are piled high with eggs, cheese, and your choice of breakfast meats, while the lunch menu features fresh sandwiches, wraps, and salads. All bagels are baked fresh daily using traditional New York methods.

🥯 Signature Items:

• New York-style bagels (14% protein rolls)  
• Creative flavors (Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Jalapeño-Cheddar, Oreo)  
• Loaded breakfast sandwiches  
• Fresh wraps and salads  
• Bagel and cream cheese combos

✨ Why Visit: 

Craving a real bagel in the Florida Keys? This is your spot. The authentic NY-style preparation and creative flavor combinations make it the best breakfast option for bagel lovers in Marathon.

👥 Perfect For: Bagel lovers • Quick breakfast • Authentic NY-style experience • Breakfast sandwiches

🏠 Atmosphere: Casual bagel shop, quick breakfast/lunch