Authentic New York-Style Pizza in the Keys

🌟 Famous For: NY Water Maker Machine for Perfect Pizza Dough

📍 Location: 61 53rd St, Marathon, FL 33050 (across from Publix)  
📏 Distance from East Sister Rock: ~2 miles  
💰 Price Range: $-$$ (Budget-friendly to Moderate)  
⏰ Hours: 11am - 9pm daily

About:

Coast to Coast Pizza Company brings authentic New York-style pizza to Marathon, using a special NY Water Maker machine that replicates New York City water to achieve the perfect dough texture and flavor. This veteran-owned family pizzeria is Marathon's answer to pizza lovers' prayers, offering handmade pizzas crafted by certified pizzaiolos with top-quality ingredients.

Located across from Publix in Marathon (the former Big Mouth space), Coast to Coast offers slices or whole pies for dine-in, carry-out, and online orders. The authentic NY preparation method, quality ingredients, and passionate approach to pizza-making have quickly made this the best pizza spot in the Florida Keys.

🍕 Signature Items: 

• Authentic NY-style pizza (using NY Water Maker)  
• Traditional hand-tossed dough  
• Quality toppings and fresh ingredients  
• Available by the slice or whole pie  
• Dine-in, carry-out, and online ordering

✨ Why Visit:   

Craving real New York pizza in the Florida Keys? Coast to Coast is the closest you'll get to authentic NY-style pizza south of Miami. The use of NYC water replication technology and traditional preparation methods makes all the difference.

👥 Perfect For: Pizza lovers • Authentic NY-style experience • Family dining • Take-out

🏠 Atmosphere: Casual pizzeria, veteran-owned family business